Thread:LostRunes/@comment-33255590-20190313031512

Hiyo! So I'd like to explain my edit a little bit here so here it is: I probably typed that piece of trivia wrong. But Edward is indeed an Atheist. This only exists in the Japanese Subs, but it is indeed in both anime. Edward in 2003 talks about how "scientists will find a way", basically putting Science above religion in finding a way to bring people back to life. In Brotherhood's Subs, when Rose asks if Ed is interested in learning about Letoism, he replies simply, "Sorry, but I'm an Atheist", which was carried over into Brotherhood's subs. Edward's dialogue was changed from the Dub to Vic Mignogna, many other fans believe the same. If you want someone with a decent amount of detail on the subject, there's GoatJesus, which is actually where I initially learned about Ed and his Atheism. He does a good job summing up some of the religious stuff in both FMA 2003 and Brotherhood. He also does a good job of comparing the two shows. I'll leave links here to them, the videos are a little hard for myself to follow and GJ uses a lot of real-world connections to connect stuff to the show. But Ed's Atheism is shown briefly in both videos. But it's definitely there, and yes he doesn't say anything about "not caring about god" in Brotherhood's dub. Anywho, thanks for letting me know about it, I could be completely wrong here. Just let me know and I'll remove it ASAP. Thank you!

Nario (talk)

FMA 2003 and Religion

FMA Brotherhood and Religion

FMA 2003 Vs. Brotherhood Comparison (Part 2) (You might have to watch Part 1 as well to understand some context of certain conditions.) 