Forum:Is evny a guy or a girl?

this is something i just haven't been able figure out. Icedeath 05:44, November 9, 2009 (UTC)

Envy isn't a boy or girl, but is usally refered to as a he, but looks kinda like a girl. Confusing, ae. --DARK 21:26, November 9, 2009 (UTC)

In the 2003 Anime, Envy is a boy. In the Manga and 2009 Anime, Envy is most likely a boy, yet he/she could be genderless. --Comp0(Unregistered)

I would go with genderless. To me Envy looks like a girl with a significant amount of boy-like characteristics that make it hard to actually differentiate. He/She certainly has a feminine voice and as far as his/her clothing goes, the top makes it hard to figure out if he/she actually has breasts or not. It's safe to say there's no gender and I think it makes sense since Envy's all about imitating other people. OutOf Timer  Wanna chat?  23:44, February 6, 2010 (UTC)

In the 2003 anime he reveals himself to be the result of a failed human transmutation involving, i assume, Edward's half brother due to the resemblence and a comment made by him before he kills Edward. In the manga the other homunculi refer to him as a he multiple times, even though id refer to him as more of an it due to his true form being a gigantic 6 legged monster. 22:48, February 13, 2010 -(Unregistered)

Actually, in the manga he's never refered to as "he", since there's no such gender definition in Japanese stated in the lines of the manga: it's an adaptation of translations. But, in fact, just as any other homunculi, Envy is genderless: he's a sin and we call it a "he" because the sin "Envy" is usually associated as "he", just as Lust is a sin associated as "she", but that's merely a linguistical convention. But it's a "He" in the 2003 anime, since he was created from the son of Hohenheim.Turdaewen 23:03, February 24, 2012 (UTC)